Shelby's Pizza

Tausif Shahid 2 months ago

We love Shelbys specialty Pizzas like The Works. They accommodate our request for topping substitutions with no issues and it is always consistent same tasting fresh Pizzas.

Wisam Khalil 2 months ago

As someone who has spent years in the food business and is considered a food critic because of my profession, I can honestly say this is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The Spicy Buffalo Pizza is, without a doubt, the best buffalo pizza I’ve ever tasted. Absolutely phenomenal. From the perfectly crafted dough, to the rich tomato sauce, the premium-quality cheese, and the outstanding cleanliness—everything is on point. The flavor is incredible, and what I love most is that it doesn’t feel heavy at all. The real test?? Even if you have leftovers, just reheat them the next day, and they taste almost as fresh as when they first came out of the oven. Absolutely outstanding pizza. Highly recommended! 🍕🔥

Mayra Tavira 3 months ago

Update 20 min after receiving my order: I found a black long hair in my pizza and the pizzas were very soggy Very disappointing experience. I placed an order for 10 pizzas with over two hours’ notice and arrived at the agreed pickup time, only to find that my order hadn’t even been started. I was told their “system didn’t ring up the order.” While I understand that technical issues can happen, a large order like this should have been recognized and prepared regardless. As a small business, I would expect better organization and planning, especially for an order of this size. This was extremely frustrating and caused a significant inconvenience. It’s especially unfortunate because the business I work for orders from here regularly, but after this experience, we’ll be taking our business elsewhere.

Danish Jafri 7 months ago

Ordered two large for $28 deal. Got the spicy buffalo chicken and Alfredo chicken. Kids love it and they have halal meat options on request. Have tried their Philly steak sandwich also which is very good oven baked aswell.

Mr. Anderson a year ago

Used to get great pizza here. One time they raised the prices 30% all at once and I still bought pizza here because it was that good. I stopped ordering for a while until recently. Totally different experience now. I tried twice to make sure it wasn't a one off. I got the same exact thing both times. The thick crust is no longer thick crust. The extra cheese isn't extra at all. It was barely ok for the regular amount. The pizza was overcooked making the cheese get hard and the toppings dry. The difference is so stark it's kind of amazing. They've messed up my orders once or twice before but it seems every pizza place does at some point. These last 2 were pitiful and in the same exact way. The skimpy ingredients seems like a try at increasing profit by giving less for the price. I saw a bad review for all the same reasons from 2 months ago so obviously nothing effective has been done to change it. Anyway I'll not be ordering here anymore. Not interested in having to complain in order to get good food. I like my pizza on Friday nights way too much to risk getting bad pizza again after I've paid well and waited anxiously for it to arrive. Im not interested in coupons or anything for